Greenwashing as a Crime and the Urgency of Redesigning the Environmental Criminal Law Paradigm
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.19184/jkph.v5i1.53693Keywords:
Criminal Law, Environmental, GreenwashingAbstract
Greenwashing, a deceptive practice wherein corporations falsely present their products, services, or policies as environmentally friendly, has emerged as a serious threat to environmental protection and consumer trust in the era of sustainable development. This paper argues that greenwashing should be recognised not merely as an ethical or regulatory violation but as a criminal offence within the framework of environmental criminal law. Through a normative-juridical approach combined with a comparative analysis of legal frameworks in various jurisdictions, this study explores the limitations of current civil and administrative sanctions in deterring greenwashing practices. The analysis reveals that the absence of criminal liability has allowed corporations to manipulate sustainability narratives without facing substantial legal consequences. By examining the socio-legal harms of greenwashing, including environmental degradation, market distortion, and erosion of public confidence, this paper advocates for a paradigm shift in environmental law enforcement. It proposes the integration of greenwashing as a distinct criminal act under environmental law, emphasising principles such as strict liability, corporate criminal responsibility, and the need for restorative justice mechanisms. The study concludes with policy recommendations for legal reform that align with the principles of ecological justice and sustainable governance, reinforcing the urgency to criminalise greenwashing as part of a broader effort to protect both the environment and the rights of consumers.
Downloads
References
Akhmad, Akhmad, Zico Junius Fernando & Papontee Teeraphan, “Unmasking Illicit Enrichment: A Comparative Analysis of Wealth
Acquisition Under Indonesian, Thailand and Islamic Law” (2023) 8:2 Journal of Indonesian Legal Studies 899–934.
Bank, Edward, “Fashion’s Greenwashing Problem and How to Better Protect Consumers” (2024) SSRN Electron Journal 1–18.
Bergeson, Lynn L, “Selling green: US FTC releases proposed revisions to the “Green Guides”” (2011) 20:3 Environmental Quality Management 77–83.
Carmichael, Ruthie, “Exploring Environmental Inequalities among Marginalized Communities across the World” (2023) 1:1 International Journal of Humaniy and Social Sciences 30–40.
Clancy, Peter & L Anders Sandberg, “Formulating standards for sustainable forest management in Canada” (1997) 6:4 Business Strategy and the Environment 206–217.
De Silva, Isabelle, “Tackling the Challenges Raised by the Digitalization of the Economy: Recent Experiences of the French Competition Authority” (2019) 64:1 The Antitrust Bulletin 3–10.
Dermawan, Ahmad, Otto Hospes & CJAM Termeer, “Between zerodeforestation and zero-tolerance from the state: Navigating strategies of palm oil companies of Indonesia” (2022) 136 Forest Policy and Economics 1–10.
Devitt, Isabel, “Greenwashing in the Meat and Seafood Industry” (2024) 6 University of South Australia Law Review 55-75.
Dewi, Patricia Citra & Dwi Desi Yayi Tarina, “The Impact of Greenwashing Advertising on Consumer Behavior” (2024) 7:2 Jurnal Hukum Magnum Opus 174–183.
Effendi, Erdianto et al, “Trading in influence (Indonesia): A critical study” (2023) 9:1 Cogent Social Science 1–13.
Farkhan, Muhammad, “Mengkaji Jangkauan Hukum Positif terhadap Greenwashing: Analisis terhadap Beberapa Peraturan Perundangundangan” (2024) 4:2 Jurnal Persaingan Usaha 112–124.
Fernando, Angeline Gautami, Bharadhwaj Sivakumaran & L Suganthi, “Nature of green advertisements in India: Are they greenwashed?” (2014) 24:3 Asian Journal of Communication 222–241.
Gambier, Leila Elgaaied & Laurent Bertrandias, “Environmental Regulations and Awareness-raising Campaigns: Promoting Behavioral Change through Government Interventions” in Marketing for Sustainable Development: Rethinking Consumption Models, 1st ed (London: ISTE Ltd and John Wiley & Sons, Inc, 2021) 157.
Hofer, Matthias & Iris Amschl, “Greenwashing und UWG: Ein kurzes Update” (2024) 4:2 Nachhaltrecht 131–135.
Irawati, Paramita Prananingtyas & Retno Catur Wulan, “Regulation Urgency of the Misleading “Greenwashing” Marketing Concept in Indonesia” (2023) 1270:1 IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science 1–8.
Jaiswal, Sejal, “Greenwashing and the Ethics of CSR” (2024) 6:5 International Journal For Multidisciplinary Research 1-14.
Jestratijevic, Iva, James O Uanhoro & Md Rafiqul Islam Rana, “Transparency of sustainability disclosures among luxury and massmarket fashion brands: Longitudinal approach” (2024) 436 Journal of Cleaner Production 1–8.
Johnson, Erik W, Jennifer Schwartz & Alana R Inlow, “The criminalization of environmental harm: a study of the most serious environmental offenses prosecuted by the U.S. federal government, 1985-2010” (2020) 6:3 Environmental Sociology 307–321.
Kanie, Norichika et al, “Rules to goals: emergence of new governance strategies for sustainable development” (2019) 14:6 Sustainability Science 1745–1749.
Le Duc, Anthony, “The Multiple Contexts of the Environmental Crisis” (2020) SSRN Electron Journal 1-30.
Lyon, Thomas P & A Wren Montgomery, “The Means and End of Greenwash” (2015) 28:2 Organization and Environment 223–249.
Marcatajo, Gabriella, “Green Claims, Green Washing and Consumer Protection in the European Union” (2023) 30:1 Journal of Financial Crime 143–153.
Markham, David, Anshuman Khare & Terry Beckman, “Greenwashing: A Proposal To Restrict Its Spread” (2014) 16:04 Journal Environmental Assessment Policy and Management 1–8.
Meidinger, Errol E, “Environmental Certification Systems and U.S. Environmental Law: Closer than You May Think” (2005) SSRN Electron Journal 1–18.
Rexroth, Annette, “Green Claims oder Greenwashing - was ist erlaubt und was tidak?” (2023) 77:S3 Lebensmittelchemie 1–7.
Salim, Agus, Ria Anggraeni Utami & Zico Junius Fernando, “Green Victimology: Sebuah Konsep Perlindungan Korban Dan Penegakan Hukum Lingkungan Di Indonesia” (2022) 7:1 Bina Hukum Lingkungan 59–79.
Somany, Nirvaan, “Greenwashing In Business: Examining The Impact Of Deceptive Environmental Claims On Consumer Behavior And
Corporate Accountability” (2023) 08:04 International Journal of Social Science and Economic Research 908–920.
Spaniol, Matthew J. et al, “Defining Greenwashing: A Concept Analysis” (2024) 16:20 Sustainability 1-17.
Zentoni, Budi Santoso & David M L Tobing, “Mengkriminalisasi Greenwashing: Menjawab Tantangan Perlindungan Konsumen di
Era Keberlanjutan: Criminalizing Greenwashing: Addressing Consumer Protection Challenges in the Era of Sustainability” (2025) 26:1 Jurnal Litigasi 102–137.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Zico Junius Fernando, Wevy Efticha Sary, Ahmad Wali, Ariesta Wibisono Anditya
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
