Dilemma of Legal Transplantation in CCS Regulations: Between Harmonization and Adaptation to Local Context
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.19184/jkph.v4i2.51726Keywords:
Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS), CCS Regulation, Legal TransplantationAbstract
Climate change necessitates innovative solutions like Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) to reduce CO2 emissions. CCS involves capturing and storing CO2 in underground geological formations. Implementing CCS in Indonesia requires a comprehensive regulatory framework addressing technical standards, permits, monitoring, and financing, while also considering environmental and social risks. This research analyzes the dilemma of "legal transplantation" in Indonesian CCS regulations, balancing harmonization with international standards and adaptation to local contexts. Legal transplantation involves adopting legal rules from one jurisdiction to another. In this context, it might involve incorporating international best practices into Indonesian law. This raises questions about reconciling foreign legal elements with existing Indonesian legal frameworks and the country's unique context. This research employs normative legal methods with a qualitative approach. Data was gathered through literature reviews, comparative analysis, case studies, and comprehensive interviews. This study examines the impact of legal transplantation on developing CCS regulations in Indonesia, analyzing the challenges and opportunities in adapting regulations from other countries. It explores achieving a balance between global harmonization and local adaptation. Utilizing normative legal research methods with a qualitative approach, this research aims to contribute to developing effective and sustainable CCS regulations in Indonesia. With a suitable regulatory framework, CCS can be a crucial tool in mitigating climate change.
Downloads
References
Adefila, Kehinde & YongYan, A Compendium of CO2 Leakage Detection and Monitoring Techniques in Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) Pipelines (2013) Journal Abbreviation: Eurocon, pp. 1328-1335.
Adisaputro, Didi & Bastian Saputra, “Carbon Capture and Storage and Carbon Capture and Utilization: What Do They Offer to Indonesia?” (2017) 5 Frontiers in Energy Research
Agung, I Gusti Ngurah, “Implementasi Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) Sebagai Upaya Mitigasi Perubahan Iklim Di Indonesia: Studi Perbandingan Dengan Norwegia” (2019) 10:2 Jurna Ilmu Hukum 141–152.
Almeida, Fernando, “Strategies To Perform A Mixed Methods Study” (2018) 4:1 Europian Juornal Educational Studies 137151.
Amijaya, Hendra, “Geological Cnsideration For CO2 Storage in Indonesia” (2015) 1:1 Journal of Applied Geology.
Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan ESDM, Kajian Potensi Pemanfaatan Teknologi Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) di Indonesia (Jakarta: Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral, 2019).
Benuf, Kornelius & Muhamad Azhar, “Metodologi Penelitian Hukum sebagai Instrumen Mengurai Permasalahan Hukum Kontemporer” (2020) 7:1 Jurnal Gema Keadilan 20–33.
Bouckaert, Stéphanie et al, Net Zero by 2050: A Roadmap for the Global Energy Sector (France: International Energy Agency, 2021).
Bui, Mai et al, “Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS): The Way Forward” (2018) 11:5 Energy Enviromental Science Journal 1062–1176.
Döbbeling-Hildebrandt, Niklas et al, “Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Ex-post Evaluations on The Effectiveness of Carbon Pricing” (2024) 15:1 Nature Communication 1–12.
El-Kady, Ahmed Hamd, “Analysis of CO2 Pipeline Regulations from A Safety Perspective For Offshore Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS)” (2024) 439 Journal of Cleaner Production 140734.
Fuss, Sabine, “Negative Emissions-Part 2: Costs, Potentials and Side Effects” (2018) 13:6 Environmental Research Letters 1–47.
Gola, Swati & Kyriaki Noussia, “From CO2 Sources to Sinks: Regulatory Challenges for Trans-boundary Trade, Shipment and sSorage” (2022) 179 Resour Conserv Recycling Journal.
IEA, CCUS in Clean Energy Transitions. IEA Publications., by IEA (Paris, 2020).
International Energy Agency, Energy Technology Perspectives: Special Report on Carbon Capture Utilisation and Storage CCUS in clean energy transitions 2020 (France: International Energy Agency, 2020).
Kementerian Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral (ESDM), Grand Strategi Energi Nasional, by Kementerian Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral (ESDM) (Jakarta, 2021).
Klenert, D, “Making Carbon Pricing Work For Citizens” (2018) 8:8 National Climate Changes Journal 669–677.
Lechtenböhmer & Schlömer, “Transnational Legal Perspectives on CCS: A Comparative Analysis of The US, EU, and China.” (2017) 109 Journal of Energy Policy 641–652.
Mabon, Leslie & Wan-Yu Shih, “Urban Greenspace as A Climate Change Adaptation Strategy for Subtropical Asian Cities: A Comparative Study Across Cities in Three Countries” (2021) 68 Journal of Global Environmental Change 102248.
Matt, Steyn et al, Global Status of CCS 2022 (Australia: The Global CCS Institute, 2022).
Mills, Maria B, “Tropical forests post-logging are a persistent net carbon source to the atmosphere” (2023) 120:3 The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Journal 1–7.
Nelson, Katherine A, “The Role of Payment for Ecosystem Services in Incentivizing Carbon Sequestration in Agricultur” (2014) 38:2 Enviromental Science and Policy Journal 118–128.
Pamungkas, Bima Niko & Vissia Dewi Haptari, “Analisis Skema Pengenaan Pajak Karbon Di Indonesia Berdasarkan United Nations Handbook Mengenai Penerapan Pajak Karbon Oleh Negara Berkembang” (2022) 6:2 Jurnal Pajak Indonesia.
Patle, Ghanshyam, Bandyopadhyay & Singh, “Impact of conservation agriculture and resource conservation technologies on carbon sequestration–a review” Indian Journal of Agricultural Science.
Prasetyo, Ahmad Wisnu & Jaka Windarta, “Pemanfaatan Teknologi Carbon Capture Storage (CCS) dalam Upaya Mendukung Produksi Energi yang Berkelanjutan” (2022) 3:3 Jurnal Energi Baru Dan Terbarukan 231–238.
Purwanto & Suhartono, “Potensi dan Tantangan Penerapan Teknologi Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) di Indonesia” (2020) 21:1 Jurnal Teknologi dan Lingkungan.
Putri, Arananda Dwi, Nugroho Adi Sasongko & Donny Yoesgiantoro, “Carbon Capture Storage dan Carbon Capture Utilization Storage (CCS/CCUS) sebagai Solusi Transisi Energi Fosil di Indonesia” (2024) 8:2 Pendipa Journal Science and Education 191–203.
Silk, Ian, “Quest Carbon Capture & Storage Project” (2011) 1 Strategy 1–12.
Solomon, Semere, “Carbon Dioxide Storage: Geological Security and Environmental Issues-Case Study on the Sleipner Gas field in Norway” (2007) Bellona Report 128.
Sugihardjo, “Penyaringan dan Peringkat Cekungan Kalimantan Timur serta Potensinya untuk Implementasi CCUS” (2021) 55:3 Lembaran Publikasi Minyak Dan Gas Bumi 171–185.
Swennenhuis, Floris et al, “What Role for CCS in Delivering Just Transitions? An Evaluation in The North Sea region” (2020) 9:4 International Journal Green Gas Control.
Tanikawa, W & Michael, “Geological Storage of Carbon Dioxide in Indonesia: A Review of The Potential and Challenges” (2022) 10:1 International Journal Green Gas Control 101–120.
Usman, “Prospect For Co2 Eor To Offset The Cost Of CCS At Coal Power Plants” (2018) 39:3 Journal of Science Contribution Oil Gas 107–118.
Wibowo, Suyanto Edi, “Memahami Makna Pasal 33 Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945 Perihal Penguasaan Oleh Negara Terhadap Sumber Daya Alam"(2016) 18:1 Jurnal Konstitusi.
Zaemi, Fiqya Fairuz & Rian Cahya Rohmana, “Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) untuk Pembangunan Berkelanjutan: Potensi dan Tantangan di Industri Migas Indonesia” (2021) 3:1 Prosiding Seminar Nasional Teknik Lingkungan Kebumian (Satu Bumi) Ke-III.
Zhang, Hao, “Regulations for carbon capture, utilization andstorage: Comparative analysis of development in Europe, China and the Middle East”, (2021)173 Resources, Conservation and Recycling Journal.
Zhang, Ting, Mei Jie & Wang Hao, The Regulatory Model of Carbon Capture and Storage Technologies (Ccs) in China the Perspective of Central-Local Government Relations(2023)SSRN Journal.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Wahyu Fahmi Rizaldy, Elbouche Chems Sadjda Lilleh
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
