Integrating Reproductive Justice Approaches in the Human Rights Framework: A Comparative Analysis of the U.S.A., India, and Indonesia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.19184/jkph.v4i1.46509Keywords:
Constitutionalism, Reproductive Rights, Sexual HealthAbstract
Sexual health and reproductive rights have become instrumental in defining the constitutional horizons and constitutionalism thereof of a country. In this context, Roe v. Wade emerged as an authority on the issue of abortion, bodily integrity, and sexual health which traveled in various jurisdictions. The paper purports to explore the underlying complexities and challenges in asserting reproductive rights by undertaking a comparative study of the constitutional and legal framework in the U.S.A., India, and Indonesia. The research work carried out is socio-legal, the social realities to elaborate social phenomena about existing legal facts, and the author assessed and analyzed the status of reproductive rights in the U.S.A, India, and Indonesia through a comprehensive analysis of case laws decided by constitutional courts of these countries. The global debate on women's reproductive rights, championed by feminists, emphasizes the urgent need to eradicate gender stereotypes for true equality. Despite progress, many countries still face challenges due to religious, cultural, and socio-economic biases. Access to contraceptives, abortion rights, and information remains limited. Promoting equal parenting and raising awareness are crucial. Legal mechanisms, like Roe v. Wade, have advanced reproductive rights, but regressive rulings like Dobbs pose threats. The demands of diverse communities, including same-sex couples, require revisiting legal frameworks. Constitutionalizing these rights and allocating funds for awareness and healthcare are vital steps. Governments must address child marriage and provide inclusive sex education, prioritizing reproductive health as a fundamental human right.
Downloads
References
Aeniwati, Zahri and Sri Kusriyah, “Criminal Responsibility towards Criminals of Abortion in Indonesia” (2021) 3:1 Law Development Journal 9–18.
Alice, “Why Birth Control Remains Just Out of Reach for Most Indonesian Women” (24 August 2017), online: VICE https://www.vice.com/en/article/a33n3g/why-birth-control-remains-just-out-of-reach-for-most-indonesian-women.
Anna Kharina Mangold, “Feminist Constitutionalism: Global Perspectives” (2013) 11 International Journal of Constitutional Law 1124–1129.
Ariyad and Masyhar, “Abortion by Rape Victim: A Dilemma in the Draft of Penal Code and Indonesian Health Law” (2020) 1:4 Journal of Law and Legal Reform 631–640, online: https://doi.org/10.15294/jllr.v1i4.39659.
Armiwulan, Hesti, “Rights to Abortion, Pro-Choice vs. Pro-Life: Case of Indonesia and the USA” (2022) 17:2 International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences 128–139.
Aysha Hasna Zhafirah, “The Overturning of Roe v. Wade as a Form of Post-Colonialism” (2023) Jurnal Perempuan dan Anak, online: https://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/JPA/article/view/23616.
Bachpan Bachao Andolan, “Writ Petition”, online: Bachpan Bachao Andolan https://bba.org.in/writs/.
Berer, M, “Abortion Law and Policy Around the World: In Search of Decriminalization” (2017) 19:1 Health and Human Rights.
Beverley Baines, Daphne Barak-Erez and Tsvi Kahana, Feminist Constitutionalism: Global Perspectives (Cambridge University Press, 2012).
Beverly Baines and Ruth Rubio-Marin, The Gender of Constitutional Jurisprudence (Cambridge University Press, 2004).
Bhirawa Anoraga and Minako Sakai, “From Pemuda to Remaja” (2023) 51:1 Indonesia and the Malay World.
Brenda Cossman, “Gender Performance, Sexual Subjects, and International Law” (2002) 15 Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 281–282.
Brenda Cossman, “Gender Performance, Sexual Subjects, and International Law” (2002) 15 Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 281–28.
Bunch, Charlotte, “Strengthening Human Rights of Women” in M Nowak, ed, World Conference on Human Rights—The Contribution of NGOs: Reports and Documents (Vienna: Manzsche Verlags-und Universitätsbuchhandlung, 1994) 32–41.
Bunch, Charlotte, “Women’s Rights as Human Rights: Toward a Re-Vision of Human Rights” (1990) 12:4 Human Rights Quarterly 486–498.
Candra, Septia, Hukum Aborsi bagi Korban Perkosaan Menurut Fatwa Majelis Ulama Indonesia No 4 Tahun 2005 tentang Aborsi dan Undang-Undang No 36 Tahun 2009 tentang Kesehatan (diploma, UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung, 2019).
Carolin Schurr and Elisabeth Militz, “Reproductive Rights” in International Encyclopedia of Human Geography, 2nd ed (2020).
CESCR, General Comment No 14: The Right to the Highest Attainable Standard of Health, UN Doc E/C.12/2000/4 (2000), online: https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/4538838d0.pdf.
Christine de Pizan, The Book of the City of Ladies, translated by Earl Jeffery Richards (Persea Books, 1982) (1405).
Colombian Constitutional Court, Decision C-355/2006.
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Forty-Fifth Session, Summary Record of the 49th Meeting, online: https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G10/466/41/PDF/G1046641.pdf?OpenElement.
Copelon, Rhonda and Sylvia Ann Law, “‘Nearly Allied to Her Right to Be’—Medicaid Funding for Abortion: The Story of Harris v McRae” in Elizabeth M Schneider & Stephanie M Wildman, eds, Women and the Law Stories (Foundation Press, 2011), online: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2178231.
Diniz, D, “Selective Abortion in Brazil: The Anencephaly Case” (2007) Development World Bioethics.
Dipika Jain, “Supreme Court of India Judgment on Abortion as a Fundamental Right: Breaking New Ground” (2023), online: PMC https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10321178/.
Donald Kommers, The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany (Duke University Press, 1997).
Erdman and James Cook, “Reproductive Rights” in Harald Kristian (Kris) Heggenhougen, ed, International Encyclopedia of Public Health (Oxford: Academic Press, 2008) 532.
Fellmeth, Aaron Xavier, “Feminism and International Law: Theory, Methodology, and Substantive Reform” (2000) 22:3 Human Rights Quarterly 658–733.
Fraser, Arvonne, “Becoming Human: The Origins and Development of Women’s Human Rights” (1999) 21:4 Human Rights Quarterly.
Friedman, “Gendering the Agenda: The Impact of the Transnational Women’s Rights Movement at the UN Conferences of the 1990s” (2003) 26:4 Women’s Studies International Forum 313–331.
Gafar A, Suza DE, Efendi F, Has EMM, Pramono AP & Susanti IA, “Determinants of Contraceptive Use among Married Women in Indonesia” (2020) 9 F1000Research 193.
Grant MJ, “The Demographic Promise of Expanded Female Education: Trends in the Age at First Birth in Malawi” (2015) 41:3 Population and Development Review.
Gutbrod, Elena, “Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization” (2022) The Reporter: Social Justice Law Center Magazine 2022, art 4 at 88.
Hirschl, Ran, “‘Negative’ Rights vs Positive Entitlements: A Comparative Study of Judicial Interpretations of Rights in an Emerging Neo-Liberal Economic Order” (2000) 22:4 Human Rights Quarterly.
Hirsh Shah, “Aftermath of the Hobby Lobby Decision: Implications for Women in the Workforce” (2016) Auctus: The Journal of Undergraduate Research and Creative Scholarship, Virginia Commonwealth University, online: https://scholarscompass.vcu.edu/auctus/50?utm_source=scholarscompass.vcu.edu%2Fauctus%2F50&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPages.
Isdian Anggreany, “Urgensi Pelaksanaan Tahapan Persiapan Penyusunan Kontrak oleh Pelaku Bisnis dalam Mengkonstruksi Hubungan Bisnis” (2019), online: Yurispruden https://riset.unisma.ac.id/index.php/yur/article/view/501.
Ishwara Bhat, “Methodology of Feminist Legal Research” in Idea and Methods of Legal Research, online: Oxford Academic https://academic.oup.com/book/41749/chapter-abstract/354163749?redirectedFrom=fulltext&login=false.
Jeffrey Hannan, “Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization and the Likely End of the Roe v Wade Era” (2022) 17 Duke Journal of Constitutional Law and Public Policy 281–302.
Joan Kelly, Women, History, and Theory (University of Chicago Press, 1984).
John Stuart Mill, The Subjection of Women (MIT Press, 1970).
Julia Gebhard and Diana Trimino, “Reproductive Rights, International Regulation” in Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law.
JWB and SMB (Marion’s Case), Department of Health & Community Services v (1992).
Karen Noelia Llantoy Huaman v Peru, Communication No 1153/2003, UN Doc CCPR/C/85/D/1153/2003 (2005).
Kathleen M Sullivan, “Constitutionalizing Women’s Equality” (2002) 90 California Law Review 735.
Landiyanto, Erlangga Agustino, “Abortion Policy in Indonesia: Rights, Law and Religious Perspectives” (2 April 2010), online: SSRN https://ssrn.com/abstract=1583403.
M Pentikäinen, “Applicability of the Human Rights Model to Address Concerns and the Status of Women”, online: https://tiedekirja.fi/sv/applicability-of-the-human-rights-model-to-address-concerns-and-the-status-of-women.
Mahesh, “Women Rights are Human Rights: A Legal Study in Indian Perspective” (2020).
Marlina, Tat and Duwi Handoko, “Problematika Pemenuhan Hak Menyampaikan Pendapat dan Pelanggaran terhadap Hak atas Kesehatan di Indonesia” (2021) 3 Ensiklopedia of Journal 42–53.
Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (Source Book Press, 1971) (1792).
Mary Ziegler, “Beyond Backlash: Legal History, Polarization, and Roe v Wade” (2014) Washington and Lee Law Review.
Mayeri, Serena, “Constitutional Choices: Legal Feminism and the Historical Dynamics of Change” (2004) 92:3 California Law Review 755–839.
Misbah and Setyaningrum, A, “Rising Islamic Conservatism in Indonesia” in Leonard C Sebastian, Ioannis Mylonas and Klaus Friese, eds, Islamic Groups and Identity Politics.
Mylonas, Ioannis and Klaus Friese, “Indications for and Risks of Elective Cesarean Section” (2015) 112:29–30 Deutsches Ärzteblatt International 489–495.
Pillai, Vijayan K and Guang-Zhen Wang, “Reproductive Rights in Developing Countries: An Assessment of Regional Variations” (1999) 13 Michigan Sociological Review 10–27.
Pruitt, “To Recognize the Tyranny of Distance: A Spatial Reading of Whole Woman’s Health” (2019) Journal of Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space.
Rebecca Cook, “International Human Rights and Women’s Reproductive Health” (1993) 24:2 Studies in Family Planning 73–86, online: https://doi.org/10.2307/2939201.
“Reproductive Rights and Reproductive Health”, Chapter VII, “A Programme of Action—Adopted at the International Conference on Population and Development” (1994), online: UNFPA https://www.unfpa.org/sites/default/files/eventpdf/PoA_en.pdf.
Rob Kitchin and Nigel Thrift, International Encyclopedia of Human Geography, online: ScienceDirect http://www.sciencedirect.com:5070/referencework/9780081022962/international-encyclopedia-of-human-geography.
Roe v Wade and the Right to Privacy, Center for Reproductive Rights, online: https://reproductiverights.org/sites/default/files/documents/roeprivacy_0.pdf.
Rosalind Dixon and Martha Nussbaum, “Abortion, Dignity and a Capabilities Approach” (2012) Cambridge University Press.
Ruth Bader Ginsburg, “Thoughts on Autonomy and Equality in Relation to Roe v Wade” (1985) 63 North Carolina Law Review 375.
Sarah Parshall Perry and Thomas Jipping, Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization: An Opportunity to Correct a Grave Error, The Heritage Foundation, online: http://report.heritage.org/lm293.
Scott, Joan W, “Gender: A Useful Category of Historical Analysis” (1986) 91:5 The American Historical Review 1053–1075.
Snyder, R Claire, “Who Is Third-Wave Feminism? A New Directions Essay” (2008) 34:1 Signs.
Staggenborg, “Reproductive Rights in Affluent Nations” in International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences (2001).
Starrs AM, Ezeh AC, Barker G et al, “Accelerate Progress—Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights for All: Report of the Guttmacher-Lancet Commission” (2018) 391:10140 The Lancet 2642–2692.
Sudhinaraset M, Vilda D, Gipson JD, Bornstein M & Wallace ME, “Women’s Reproductive Rights Policies and Adverse Birth Outcomes: A State-Level Analysis to Assess the Role of Race and Nativity Status” (2020) 787–795.
Sue Ganske, “Burwell v Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc: The US Supreme Court Holds the Religious Freedom Restoration Act Trumps the Affordable Care Act” (2015) 31 Journal of Health Law and Policy 1.
Supreme Today, “Hallo Bi @ Halima v State of Madhya Pradesh—Supreme Today AI”, online: https://supremetoday.ai/doc/judgement/02702010670.
Syafiq Hasyim and Alexander R Arifianto, (2022) Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences of Southeast Asia.
Thomas Müller, “Global Constitutionalism in Historical Perspective: Towards Refined Tools for International Constitutional Histories” (2014).
Uerling, Donald, “Supreme Court Rulings on Abortion: Roe v Wade and Selected Progeny” (2006) Journal of Women in Educational Leadership.
UN Human Rights Committee (HRC), “Prohibition of Torture, or Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment”, General Comment No 20: Article 7 (10 March 1992), online: https://www.refworld.org/docid/453883fb0.html.
UNFPA Indonesia, “Strengthening Data to Reduce Maternal Deaths in Indonesia” (8 May 2023), online: https://indonesia.unfpa.org/en/news/strengthening-data-reduce-maternal-deaths-indonesia.
United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner, “Reproductive Rights Are Human Rights: A Handbook for National Human Rights Institutions”, online: https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Publications/NHRIHandbook.pdf.
Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action (1993), “The World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna”.
Warwick and Donald, “The Indonesian Family Planning Program: Government Influence and Client Choice” (1986) 12:3 Population and Development Review 453–490, online: https://doi.org/10.2307/1973219.
Williams and Ochoa, Constituting Equality: Gender Equality and Comparative Constitutional Law (Cambridge University Press, 2009).
World Bank Open Data, “World Bank Open Data”, online: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.RUR.TOTL.ZS?locations=ID.
World Health Organization, “Sexual Health, Human Rights, and the Law”, online: https://www.who.int/publications-detail-redirect/9789241564984.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Neha Tripathi, Anubhav Kumar
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
